// The AI Roundtable Kit

Put 14 AI advisors in a room. Let them fight about your homepage.

Seven grade what your page says. Seven grade how it looks. They argue across the table, vote, and hand you a score you can re-run after every change.

35.5 → 56Messaging score
40 → 63Design score
One B2B homepage, before and after a rebuild. Same rubric both times.

Get the kit, free

Six-page guide plus the Claude skill. The download opens right here.

Here you go.

Open START-HERE.md first, then build three seats per room. That's enough for a real fight.

// Messaging roomWHAT THE PAGE SAYS
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Clarity
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Positioning
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Category
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Narrative
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Awareness
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Onlyness
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Counterweight
100-point rubric2 rounds1 chair1 verdict
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Hierarchy
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Conversion
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Usability
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Art direction
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Craft
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Interaction
AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)Builder
// Design roomHOW IT LOOKS AND WORKS

Every seat is simulated and labeled that way. You build each one from public work you've read.

// Why two rooms

The fight most teams have in two different meetings.

Messaging wants the page to say more. Design answers with what the layout can carry. Usually nobody scores it. Here both sides argue at one table, against one rubric, and the argument ends in a number.

Real lines from a run on a B2B homepage.

AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)
Positioning seat → Builder seat

Buyers still choose between a book, a consultant, a survey, or nothing. It doesn’t say why you beat those.

AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)
Builder seat → Positioning seat

Three contrast rows reuse a card we already have. Small build. Keep it below the hero.

AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)
Category seat → Hierarchy seat

Name the category in one phrase. A mind needs something to reject.

AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)AvataaarsPablo Stanleyhttps://avataaars.com/https://avataaars.com/Remix of „Avataaars” (https://avataaars.com/) by „Pablo Stanley”, licensed under „Free for personal and commercial use” (https://avataaars.com/)
Hierarchy seat → Category seat

Category plus enemy plus offer in one line is three focal points. Pick one.

// How a run works

Two rounds, one chair, one verdict.

01

Gather evidence

The page as text, screenshots, and two or three options to vote on.

02

Every seat scores alone

One agent per seat, in parallel. No quote from the page, no score.

03

Cross the table

Each seat argues with the other room and changes its mind only on evidence.

04

The chair decides

Both scores, the vote, what to fix now, and what needs a real buyer test.

verdict.md · a B2B homepage
Messaging
35.5 → 56
Design
40 → 63
Headline
Better looking. Still not saying why you.
Vote
Open with the problem buyers feel 6 · Name the alternatives 5 · Move a customer story up 3
Fix now
Three contrast rows against the real alternatives. Reuses an existing card. Small build.
Cover of the AI Roundtable Kit guide
FREEGuide + Claude skill
// What's in the zip

Everything to run it on your own site.

  • AI-Roundtable-Kit-Guide.pdfSix pages: the two rooms, the rubric, how a run works, how to build a seat.
  • roundtable/SKILL.mdThe run, step by step. Drop the folder into Claude Code.
  • roundtable/rubric-messaging.md100-point scorecard for what the page says, with scoring anchors.
  • roundtable/rubric-design.md100-point scorecard for how it looks and works.
  • roundtable/chair.mdThe rules that stop the room agreeing with you.
  • roundtable/seats/A seat template plus all 14 roles, each with a reading list.
  • roundtable/templates/The shape of round 1, round 2 and the verdict.
  • START-HERE.mdSetup in Claude Code, or in a Claude.ai Project with no code.
// The seats

Fourteen seats. One question each.

Messaging room100 PTS
  • ClarityCan a stranger say what you offer, how it helps and how to buy, in five seconds?20
  • PositioningAgainst what buyers would do instead, why are we the obvious choice?30
  • CategoryWhat one word or category do we own in the buyer's mind?10
  • NarrativeWhat change in the world makes this necessary now?10
  • AwarenessHow aware is this visitor, and does the page meet them there?10
  • OnlynessFinish “the only ___ that ___.” Is it true?10
  • CounterweightIs it distinctive, and easy to remember and buy?10
Design room100 PTS
  • HierarchyOne focal point per screen, a consistent type scale, real restraint?15
  • ConversionDoes the layout help a B2B buyer decide, in the order they decide?20
  • UsabilityCan a first-time visitor use it without thinking?15
  • Art directionIs there an ownable look, or is it stock and template?15
  • CraftDoes it feel current, and does it show the product working?15
  • InteractionDo motion and interaction details add meaning and feel fast?10
  • BuilderWhat can we ship, and how big is each idea? Built from your own stack.10

The number is each seat's share of its room's score. Start with three seats per room (clarity, positioning, counterweight; hierarchy, conversion, usability) and add the rest when you want a louder room.

// Your turn

Run it on your homepage this week.

Grab the kit and build your first six seats tonight. Or have me set up the room on your site and walk you through the verdict.

The seat-per-expert idea comes from Nate Herk's roast room. This version adds the rubric so the score can be re-run.